Substitutes for Pumpkin Pie Spice: 10 Best Alternatives + FAQs!

Don’t stress if you don’t have any pumpkin pie spices on hand while creating a dish that calls for them. You may use various ingredients to give your food the flavor you want.

Pumpkin pie spice may improve the flavor of your food uniquely. Cinnamon, ginger, cloves, and nutmeg are common spices in traditional American pumpkin pie recipes.

Alternative options to pumpkin pie spice include a mixture of cloves and nutmeg, chocolate and cinnamon, clove and cinnamon mix, black pepper and cinnamon, and a range of additional ingredients.

Pumpkin Pie Spice Substitutes

In essentially any recipe that asks for this blend of seasonings, you may use the following alternatives for pumpkin pie spices. It’s up to you how much of each alternative you use and what your tastes are.

1. Cinnamon

Because cinnamon is one of the key elements in pumpkin pie spices, it can be substituted in any arrangement.

You may, although, need to use this product in lesser amounts. For starters, use half the amount of cinnamon for pumpkin pie spices and taste your dishes to determine if you need to add more.

2. Ginger and all spices mix

Pumpkin pie seasonings include ginger as well. On the other hand, the proportion of ginger is substantially less than the amount of cinnamon.

You won’t completely substitute the pumpkin pie spice with ginger. However, if you want to come closer to the flavor you desire, you may add a pinch of this item. When deciding on the quantity to utilize, think about your requirements.

3. A mix of cloves and nutmeg

When you need to substitute pumpkin pie spices, cloves and nutmeg are a terrific choice. Use one part cloves to one part nutmeg or any other spices you have on hand. As you create the mixture, keep sampling it to determine how much to use.

4. Cocoa and cinnamon

You can not go wrong with a mix of cocoa and cinnamon in a delicacy. It may be used to flavor any meal that requires pumpkin pie spice.

The key is to discover the correct ratio for the food you’re making. If you enjoy both chocolate and cinnamon, you may mix them in equal proportions to get the flavor you want. This combo works well in any dish that calls for pumpkin pie spice.

5. Cloves and cinnamon mix 

Clove is an excellent complement to cinnamon. Use the same amount if you use this instead of pumpkin pie spice. You may use as much clove and cinnamon as you wish in the mixture.

If you’re a big fan of cinnamon, use two parts cinnamon and one part clove. This will give your recipe a flavor similar to pumpkin pie spice, and it will turn out wonderfully.

6. Black peppercorns and cinnamon

Black peppercorns will give your dish an earthy flavor. When combined with cinnamon, it creates the right combination.

Combine more cinnamon than black peppercorns to taste similar to pumpkin pie spice. However, how you combine these two elements for the greatest outcomes is entirely up to you.

7. Grounded pumpkin seeds with cinnamon

Grounded pumpkin seeds may enhance the flavor of any dish, but they’re especially popular in pies.

Pumpkin seeds can be mixed with a variety of seasonings. They do, however, pair well with cinnamon, and the flavor will complement any recipe. To have a richer pumpkin flavor, use two pumpkin seeds with one part cinnamon.

8. All spices mix

There is a range of spice mixtures to choose from in the market. So, instead of pumpkin pie spice blend, choose your favorite mixture and use that.

You can also retain the same number. Choosing a blend with at least two of the seasonings found in pumpkin pie spice is a terrific technique. Even if you use a replacement, this will help you preserve a comparable flavor.

9. Star anise and cinnamon 

Although star anise is much more difficult to obtain than other spices, you will fall in love with it once you do. It has an earthy flavor that works perfectly with cinnamon to create a great meal combination.

You may use this blend instead of pumpkin pie spice in the same amount. Add two cinnamon to one part of the star anise for a deeper and richer taste.

10. Pumpkin seeds and all spices mix 

As long as the pumpkin seeds are crushed and mixed with other seasonings, they can be used as a pumpkin pie spice alternative.

You will enjoy the results if you add pumpkin seeds to any nutty spice blend. The combination of pumpkin seeds with cocoa is especially delicious, but you can use them in any spiced recipe.

Homemade Pumpkin Pie Spice Recipe

Homemade pumpkin pie spice may be prepared in a variety of ways. As a result, the greatest one relies heavily on cinnamon as a major component.

4 teaspoons of cinnamon, 3 teaspoons ground ginger, 1 teaspoon ground cloves, half a teaspoon ground nutmeg, and a little of all spices mix are required.

Keep your mixture dry by storing it in an airtight container. Or else, you won’t be getting the best out of it, and your dish won’t have the flavor you desire.

Since you can tell, making your pumpkin pie spice isn’t as difficult as it sounds. It will simply take a couple of minutes to combine the ingredients if you already have them in your cupboard.

If you have the supplies, but they aren’t ground, you’ll have to grind them as well, which will make the procedure more complicated.

Questions:-

How Can I Substitute Pumpkin Pie Spice For Individual Spices?

If you wish to switch pumpkin pie spice mix with any of the substitutions listed in this article or others of your choosing, it’s a good idea to try them out first.

If you taste it first before using it, you’ll know exactly how much spice mix to use to achieve the optimum flavor for you and your family. Spices that you have mixed in your kitchen might be used. Alternatively, you may buy several blends from your local grocery shop.

What Is Pumpkin Pie Spice Made Of? 

Pumpkin pie spice dishes come in a variety of flavors. On the other hand, the conventional recipe asks for five key components.

Cinnamon, cloves, nutmeg, ginger, and all spices blend are needed to produce a delicious pumpkin pie spice. The recipe’s versatility is preserved in the allspice blend.

You can get whichever allspice blend you like from your local supermarket. However, be sure they’re suitable for your recipe.

In the pumpkin pie spice combination, nutty spices and earthy and neutral flavors will work well.

What Is Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix Used For? 

If you want to make your cuisine a distinctive flavor, pumpkin pie spices are a perfect addition to sauces and garnishes.

This mix may also be used for sweets like pancakes, waffles, or oatmeal breakfasts. This is also a great component when making pumpkin muffins or pumpkin bread.

A small quantity of pumpkin pie spice can also be added to almost any pumpkin cookie, cake, or drink, such as pumpkin coffee.

You may use your imagination in the kitchen as you experiment with this tasty spice blend and discover that it goes well with a range of recipes.

You’ll never realize if you like anything unless you try it, and because pumpkin pie spices are so versatile, there are no predetermined restrictions to how you may use them in your dishes.