Substitutes for Peppermint Extract: 10 Best Alternatives, +FAQs!

Peppermint extract is well-known for its wide range of applications.

Peppermint extract is used in cuisine as a flavoring component and as a scenting agent in cosmetics and alleviating colds. However, getting your hands on it might be challenging. So, what options are available to you? Searching for alternatives is the most incredible option.

We’ll go over each of these alternatives in detail in today’s article so you’ll know how to apply them properly. To learn more, keep reading!

Substitutes for peppermint oil

We’ve compiled a list of the best peppermint extract alternatives that you should check out based on our exhaustive research.

No. 1 Peppermint oil

Although peppermint oil has a more pungent odor and flavor than peppermint extract, you can use it instead. It imparts the same crisp flavor to all of your dishes.

When substituting it in your recipes, remember that 1 part peppermint oil equals four parts peppermint extract.

No. 2 Schnapps (peppermint schnapps)

Peppermint schnapps is an alcoholic drink with a peppermint flavor. It’s typically used as a mixer in cocktails. Still, some people use it in their foods because it’s readily available at liquor stores. It has a strong peppermint flavor. Use one ounce of peppermint extract instead of four to five drops.

No. 3 Creme de menthe

Creme de menthe is another mint-flavored alcoholic beverage that is sweet and creamy. It comes in colorless and green varieties and can be used in cocktails and sweets. When compared to peppermint extract, it has a milder odor and flavor. As a result, half or one cup of creme de menthe per half teaspoon of peppermint extract is recommended.

No. 4 Extract of spearmint

Spearmint extract has a minty smell similar to peppermint, although there are some variances. Spearmint extract, for example, is sweeter than peppermint extract and does not have the same cooling effect. Although spearmint extract is best used in sweet foods, you can also use it in savory meals. If peppermint extract is unavailable, you can substitute spearmint in the same amount.

No. 5 Extract from watermint

Peppermint is a cross between spearmint and watermint, and it tastes like both. The methanol content in peppermint gives it a cooling effect. Watermint contains a significant amount of methanol, which gives it a cooling effect.

For this reason, watermint can be used in place of peppermint if it’s diluted. Fresh watermint herb can also be used, but you should add only a few leaves to the dish.

No. 6 Basil

You can use fresh basil leaves for peppermint extract if you can’t find any. It is a member of the mint family, having a strong fragrance similar to peppermint but a distinct flavor. With traces of peppery flavor, it strikes the perfect combination of spicy and sweet.

As a result, some people may detect a subtle difference in the dish’s overall flavor. However, we assure you that adding it to your recipes will have no negative consequences.

No. 7 Vodka with peppermint leaves

If you can’t get something you need locally, the best option is to build it yourself. All you need are peppermint leaves and vodka. Peppermint extract is also in this category.

Add the chopped peppermint leaves to a big jar with a cover. After that, add the vodka and let it sit for 1-2 months in a cold, dark spot. Your peppermint extract is now ready to use!

No. 8 Mint tea with herbs

Herbal mint tea is one of the most straightforward peppermint extract replacements. It’s something you can readily get at your local store.

You can use it instead of the extract depending on the meal you want to cook by starting with a tiny amount and then tasting the dish before adding more, as their flavors are somewhat different.

No. 9 Methanol crystals

Peppermint oil is used to make methanol crystals. They’re easy to find in stores or on the internet. Because of their perfume, flavor, and cooling feeling, they are utilized for various reasons.

Suppose you want to make perfumes, lotions, balms, shampoos, or other cosmetics. In that case, you may easily substitute translucent methanol crystals for peppermint extract.

No. 10 Rosemary

Because rosemary is a member of the mint family, its features are similar to those of the other mints. We recommend that you look for other options before trying it because it has a different flavor.

If you can’t find any other options, you can incorporate them into your savory cuisine. To achieve the most pleasing flavor, add it at the beginning of the dish.

Candy cane with red and white stripes (Peppermint Extract Substitute)

They come in various tastes, but peppermint is the most popular and widely available. Is it possible to use candy canes instead of peppermint extract?

Yes, candy canes can be used as a substitute for peppermint extract, in addition to the choices indicated above. To turn these solid candies into liquid, follow the procedure given below, and then use it like peppermint extract:

1. Fill a medium pot halfway with water and sugar.
2. Once the water has reached a boil, add the candy canes.
3. Reduce heat to low and cook for about 10-15 minutes.
4. Please remove it from the heat and cover it with a lid for 30 minutes.
5. Finally, filter the liquid to eliminate any candy cane fragments that may have remained.

Related FAQs

Is it possible to substitute vanilla extract for peppermint extract?

Peppermint extract has a strong and distinctive flavor. Vanilla extract, on the other hand, pales in comparison.

The most crucial distinction is that peppermint and vanilla are two distinct flavors. However, you can substitute vanilla extract in minimal amounts as a last resort.

Is it possible to use mint instead of peppermint extract?

Mint and peppermint are both members of the mint family; thus, you can use them interchangeably in recipes. However, keep in mind that their flavors are vastly different.

Is it possible to substitute essential oils for extracts?

Yes, you can use essential oils in place of extracts, but they are not the same.

Essential oils have a distinct aroma and flavor because they are pure and concentrated. On the other hand, extracts are moderate since they are diluted forms.