Can no-bake cookies be frozen?

No-bake cookies are one of the best types of cookies you can make. They are so quick and easy that you don’t even have to heat the oven.

You can make a lot of no-bake cookies in one batch, and if you like to cook in bulk, you’ll have tons of no-bake cookies piling up in your stockpiles. And what do you do with all the cookies? We mean more than just eating them, of course.

Can no bake cookies be frozen? You can freeze the cookies no bake and it is very simple to do. You just have to be able to seal them in an airtight container. They freeze well and you don’t have to worry about defrosting them to eat when you’re ready. 

In this guide, we’ll walk you through all the details you need to know to successfully freeze no bake cookies.

We think you’ll find it’s a pretty straightforward process that allows you to make large-scale batches or find a way to store them if you want to save some for later.

Stay with us to learn how to freeze no-bake cookies and much more.

How to Freeze No-Bake Cookies

No-bake cookies are very easy to freeze. Once done, all you have to do is let them set and cool before trying to freeze them.

Actually, some people also freeze their cookies when they don’t set well, so that’s an option as well; it’s just that in that particular circumstance you’ll have to take some extra precautions.

We recommend that you go through a short pre-freeze process to freeze your no-bake cookies, so they don’t stick together when frozen.

Even with that step, the process is really easy and takes very little preparation time.

Follow these steps to freeze your no bake cookies:

1. Let the cookies cool after making them.
2. Arrange the cookies in a single layer on a cookie sheet or some other method (preferably on a layer of parchment paper).
3. Place them like this in the freezer for about 2 hours so that the cookies are pre-frozen before long-term storage.
4. After pre-freezing, take the cookies out of the freezer and transfer them to a freezer bag or an airtight container.
5. Store the cookies in layers, separating them with wax paper or parchment paper between the layers. This helps protect them and prevent them from sticking together.
6. Once the cookies are packed and ready, seal the container.
7. Label the container and put the date on it.
8. Store unbaked cookies in the freezer this way for up to 6 months.

It’s that easy and you’ll love the no bake cookies cold when you take them out of the freezer. You have a lot of different options to use them once frozen.

You can eat them cold, frozen, at room temperature, or even slightly warmed.

Defrost No-Bake Cookies

Since we’re talking about freezing no-bake cookies, let’s talk for a moment about thawing and eating your no-bake cookies after you’ve frozen them.

The nice thing about no-bake cookies is that they don’t get very hard, even when frozen, so it’s really easy to grab a couple out of the freezer and eat them frozen if you want.

You can also put them in the fridge and let them thaw overnight and then eat them just cold. Finally, if you prefer, you can take them out of the freezer and leave them at room temperature on your kitchen counter.

The choice totally depends on your preferences or even your needs at that moment.

Proper Storage of Unbaked Cookies

We have already talked about the possibility of freezing your no bake cookies. This is one option and works well if you want to save a few for later or even make them in large batches.

However, you do not have to use the freezer. There are other ways to store your no-bake cookies and they really do keep well for a long time with no problem.

The most you have to worry about is drying out, but as long as you store them, it probably won’t be a major problem.

Let’s talk about other storage options that you can use.

Store unbaked cookies at room temperature

There is nothing in your no-bake cookies that requires you to refrigerate or freeze them. You can certainly store them in those places, but it is not required. You can store your cookies at room temperature if you want to keep it simple.

Here are some steps:

1. 1. Let the cookies cool and set as needed.
   2. Transfer your cookies to some airtight storage method. Storage bags can be very useful in this case, but you can also use a plastic container if you prefer.

1. Seal your storage method between each time you go for the cookies.

Yes, it’s that simple! You can store the no-bake cookies at room temperature for several days. They are not likely to go bad before they are all eaten.

Your biggest concern will be whether or not the cookies are going to dry out. If you store them in a cool, dry place, they should be fine.

All you need to do is keep them out of excessive heat or direct sunlight, and perhaps also away from places where they can retain excessive moisture.

Storing unbaked cookies in the fridge

Another great storage option that you can use is the fridge. If you know they are going to be eaten and you don’t want to mess with the freezer, the fridge works just as well.

You can store them at room temperature or in the fridge and get a similar shelf life.

Storing them in the fridge is also very easy. Lots of people love cold no-bake cookies, so it may be a way to enjoy them in a different way.

Follow these steps to store them in the fridge:

1. Allow your no bake cookies to cool completely and hopefully set after making and taking them out.
2. Place the cookies in some method of storage. We recommend a storage bag or perhaps a plastic container.
3. Layer the no-bake cookies with waxed paper between them to prevent them from sticking.
4. Seal your container, whatever it is.
5. Put them in the fridge and store them like that for a couple of weeks without worry.

As with any other storage method, your biggest challenge here will be keeping your cookies from drying out while in storage. Unfortunately, this is a possible side effect of storage and the ingredients used.

As long as you treat them carefully, you shouldn’t have too much trouble with this.

Related questions

We hope you find this guide to freezing no-bake cookies a valuable and helpful resource. Freezing them is quite simple, just like the other storage methods out there. No bake cookies keep very well.

Take a look at these FAQs to see if there’s anything else you might find useful too.

Can no-bake cookies that don’t set well be hardened?

Yes. Although some batches don’t set well, you can use the fridge or freezer to help firm them up a bit. Some people even recommend dipping them in melted chocolate to help hold the pieces together.

What makes no-bake cookies gooey?

It can be difficult to determine what makes your no-bake cookies slightly sticky. Some people even say that it is the type of peanut butter that is used.

What we have found is that it is usually because the mixture has been boiled too long or not long enough.

How long do no-bake cookies last?

Stored at room temperature or in the fridge, your no-bake cookies can last up to 3 weeks. It just depends on the cookie and its storage.

Sometimes they start to dry faster than this. If you store them in the freezer, you can usually store them up to 6 months for the best results.